How many copies did Fleetwood Mac's Rumours sell? Is Fleetwood Mac good? Lindsey Buckingham is underrated Lindsey Buckingham's best solo albums Most underrated guitarist of all-time What happens if Lindsey Buckingham never join Fleetwood Mac Who is Lindsey Buckingham
by Afrobutterfly
14 comments
Thank you for existing, Lindsey Buckingham
I know what you’re thinking, “Hilson is just like Lindsey Buckingham.”
And it’s true. We are a lot alike – in our dapper good looks, self-taught artistry, appreciation for a seamless pop hook, and weakness for blondes.
You may or may not have heard of Mr. Buckingham, a musician most notable for whoring his talents to a bunch of uninspired blues hacks in the mid-70s. He brought his girlfriend along for the ride and wrote a crop of anthemic radio staples watered down only by their association with the middle-of-the-road AOR crap they had the misfortune of sharing albums with.
I re-listened to Rumours for the eight gajillionth time the other day on a road trip from Gainesville to Pensacola just to make sure all of the non-Buckingham contributions sucked as much as I remembered them sucking.
They did. Except for “Oh Daddy,” which is kinda haunting in a “wish Christine McVie was as hot as she sounded” kind of way.
She’s not.
So yeah, it’s a real shame that Buckingham had to slum it with the rest of Fleetwood Mac, especially Mick Fleetwood, whose insobriety got him kicked out of John Mayall’s Bluesbreakers and into the pantheon of “Luckiest Guys Not Named Stevie Williams, Ringo Starr or Larry Coker.”
I guess he does make for a good album cover, one you’ve no doubt seen thanks, again, to the overlooked Jedi guitar genius who penned “Go Your Own Way“/ “Second Hand News“/”Never Going Back Again“/(*insert Light FM programming mainstay*).
Imagine for a second if Alfred had taken all the credit for the crime-fighting exploits of Batman. Imagine if we referenced the “Alfred Cave” and the “Alfred Mobile” and the “Alfred Signal.” Meanwhile, Bruce Wayne’s just plugging away – kicking ass, saving Gotham, looking the part all along.
Buckingham is Batman. In a perfect world, he never crosses paths with Stevie Nicks, never lends his services to McVie/Fleetwood, never drives to Los Angeles, never wastes a line like, “Won’t you lay me down in the tall grass and let me do my stuff” (gross) on a song that gets smothered to death by the melodramatic date-schlock of “Dreams.”
In a perfect world, Nicks never gets fat. But that’s a topic for another day and another writer (Bryan Holt).
It’s true that I’ve spent the last two hours contemplating Buckingham’s career because I’m trying to put off a 15-page essay on blogging (the one supplementing my 63-page essay on blogging). But it’s also true that I would be in a much better frame of mind if immaculate pop records like Out of the Cradle and Gift of Screws tapped the wells of acclaim and disposable income they so deserve.
Because this is the kind of stuff that keeps me up at night, wondering as I drift in and out of the lightest sleep why the average middle-aged son of the seventies doesn’t appreciate “You Do Or You Don’t” as much as “Edge of Seventeen” (because he doesn’t), or why “Tusk“ the song isn’t held in more esteem than Tusk the album (because it isn’t).
Sure is hard out there for a neglected guitar virtuoso. So I want you to know, Lindsey: I see you there. I think “Love Runs Deeper” shoulda been a hit. I think “Countdown” belongs in some how-to riff tome. I think “Holiday Road” is the best part of Vacation.
Keep doing what you do, Lindsey Buckingham. You complete me, bro.
- Robbie
Is that you, Mick?
Yeah, watch out I’ve sobered up
Kicked out of Bluesbreakers? Who gives a fuck….dear Lindsay, thanks for all the good times, man, too bad it took so many “blow” jobs to keep it up
I appreciate the feisty prose and your measured attempts to keep this blog mildly offensive, but not – obviously – the overall sentiment. “One of the best rhythm sections ever”? Ever? I mean, I dig the end of “The Chain” and all, but…
Hampered by schedules but not out yet….and I quote:
“Throughout it all, Fleetwood has had bassist John McVie (the “Mac” in Fleetwood Mac) at his side to form one of the greatest rhythm sections in rock history.” Modern Drummer-June 2009 issue-look it up. Emphasis on “one of”.
Deal with it.
I love their work on “Never Going Back Again.”
CAN YOU DEAL WITH THAT?????
Lennon plays a mean guitar on “Yesterday”, too.
What, you’re a surgeon now, dissecting the band into its parts? It’s an organism, integral, connected. NONE of these people would have had it any other way. Read LIndsey Buckingham’s interview with Songwriter-2006 after the debut of another solo album. And read the end of the article I quote-Mick waxes on about the working relationship they had/have. This is a team where each person knows what they bring to the score…Lindsey no more than another.
BTW, love his music.
Deal me another hand.
Look, I appreciate your persistence and our differing tastes in music. And I think the rest of Mac are perfectly talented musicians (despite my sarcasm). The bottom line is this: I don’t really like Fleetwood Mac. I prefer Buckingham’s solo albums. And all the Mac songs I do like were penned by the Jedi guitar master. That’s all.
As for the McVie/Fleetwood battery… I tend only to pay attention to the bassists/drummers of bands that rock (or groove). Give me Zep. Or give me Stones. Hell, give me REM. I really can’t concentrate on the awesomeness of Fleetwood’s drumming when it’s being rocked to sleep by one of Nicks’ sappy ballads. But that’s just me.
Btw, Mc/Fleetwood play on Buckingham’s fantastic “Gift Of Screws” (nominally, a solo outing), suggesting they should’ve changed the band’s name to Buckingham and Four Others upon Buck’s late-’74 arrival.
And I admire your research.
The only reason I emphasized the rhythm section is because, well, you questioned my judgment…I give everyone’s personal tastes their due. Unless you’re dissing Christie…love her songs and YOU don’t have to think she’s hot.
Hope you have a great time listening to Lindsey, et al, et non. I’m on the other end because I actually liked an earlier incarnation of Mac, too…oops, bad me!
Dude, you like totally want Lindsey to serenade you with “Go Your Own Way,” don’t you?
Here’s hoping you take it as well as Stevie did.
I assume this a rhetorical question.
Don’t forget that MotherFly had dinner with the “greatest rhythm section of all time.” Here’s hoping for a new solo release soon and rumour has it that Rumours will finally be reissued this year in 180 gram format.
That’s right! She’s giving Tim a serious run for his money in a 6 Degrees of MotherFly kind of way… Looking forward to hearing ‘Rumours’ with a Bud in the new jacuzzi.


Picking on Stevie Nicks pudge? Dissin’ Christine “Perfect” McVie’s beautiful, heartfelt, eloquent songs? Ragging on one of the best rhythm sections ever? And all this to uphold an acknowledged genius songwriter and uber-guitarist who, in all his classless glory, summed up his waning days of Mac by essentially stalking off to his room to sulk. Come on. By the way, I’m pretty sure he and everybody else in Mac got their “due” in royalty checks and tour dates.