The NFL: Fluent in Apologies

Dear Kellen: On second thought, you were right.

We’re sorry that one of our referees wrongfully called back your touchdown catch due to a phantom offensive pass interference call. Yes, we know it was at a crucial moment of a game that probably lost you a playoff berth. This letter will have to do.

Sincerely,

NFL

That’s a rough estimate of the letter that the Tampa Bay Buccaneers received in the mail this week from the league. It’s nothing new for the Bucs and it’s nothing new for many NFL teams.

In a season where officiating has often been lambasted, the NFL has admitted vital issues. Tampa Bay offensive coordinator Greg Olson said that this certainly isn’t the first “we’re sorry” letter that the Bucs have received this season.

“They apologized,” Olson told the St. Pete Times. “We’ve had a number of those this year. It’s real discouraging. We’ve played some tight games, but you can’t have those kinds of mistakes. It’s disappointing, obviously. Now, it wasn’t the only play in the game, but it was a critical one at a critical time.”

He also went on to say that the letters are something that coaches are not supposed to publicly discuss.

Now, believe it or not, I’m not writing this for the sole purpose of bitching about officiating. Every fan of every losing team can usually find something that the refs did that they didn’t like. I still get angry when I think about the Bert Emanuel Rule 11 years later.

The fact is, referees should be held to a higher, more public standard or the league should stop pretending that so much is expected out of them. Apology letters are absolutely pointless and a symbol of everything that is wrong with the relationship between teams and referee crews.

For players, coaches and fans, it is difficult to understand and it should be. Teams have media requirements and players get burnt at the stake of community opinion for every single mistake that they make.

But referees, a group of guys with a giant impact on every game, get to keep this strangely anonymous public reputation. Make a mistake and there are few immediate consequences.

Referees don’t have to face any cameras or sit in front of a room of 30 blood-thirsty writers. Coaches and players get fined if they openly denounce them in any way. At the most, we hear about these awkward and useless NFL letters that we’re technically not even supposed to hear about.

A quick Google search tells us that NFL officials currently earn between $42,295 and $120,998 per season depending on experience and position. That’s not a bad going rate for 21 days of work. It also does not include playoff pay and is a significant rise from the pre-2001 strike numbers when some officials made as little as $24,825 and most held day jobs.

Day job: Mr. Universe

The pay is less than other pro leagues but that is rendered incomparable when you add up days on the road and the amount of games.

So there’s no question that NFL referees are now professional referees of the most popular sport in the United States. It’s time that they’re treated as such.

Bad calls are brushed off in press conferences because they have to be. Coaches are quick to say “Well, the call isn’t what hurt us. It was this…” And that’s fine and often necessary.

While the pass interference call in Sunday’s game took a crucial six points away from the Bucs at the time, their loss was also aided by a ridiculously conservative two-minute offense that settled for a field goal while in striking distance. Good teams don’t lose to the Detroit Lions because of one bad call.

But all too often, the refusal to blame the game on an official means letting them off the hook completely. Of all the stupid letters that the NFL has sent out this year, how many have resulted in anything happening to an official? How many officials have stood toe-to-toe with a head coach and adamantly defended a call that they knew was wrong as soon as they made it?

Exhibit A

Referees have reached a comfort zone where they know that consistently bad calls aren’t the end of the world.

Why can’t we review penalties? Because it would undermine the integrity of a group that has done little to earn our trust?

Where the need to be professional isn’t always there because we rely so much on the media for our opinions and sound bites, and referees have no obligations.

It’s why there was no backlash on the referee who told Aqib Talib [and I quote] ”You play like a pussy,” after Talib approached him to dispute a teammate’s pass interference call. We didn’t even get to know the ref’s name, much less how that had anything to do with a call against Myron Lewis that would also later be determined as incorrect.

The only word to describe a letter that says “Hey, we screwed up your game but there’s nothing we can do about it now,” is frustrating. There’s no reason to send these letters. They’re nothing more than proof that the NFL has no idea how it wants to handle officials.

It’s an amateur way to hold guys accountable without really making them accountable at all.

We should expect more from the premier organization in U.S. sports.

-Bryan

Ya know what, B?

I’m much more offended by the fact that the NFL has denied viewership of its games to its fan base than I am by any human mistake made in officiating. At least those were accidental.

Unfortunately, as much as I enjoy your writing, I can’t relate to this post SINCE I WASN’T ABLE TO WATCH THE F_CKIN’ GAME!

Look, I can afford entry into Sunday’s games, or maybe I can’t. That’s not the point. I worked all weekend, Friday and Saturday, all day and night. All I wanted, as a fan (who’s interests are not being taken into consideration by the league) was the ability to watch my favorite team play while kicking back on my couch in the comfort of my own home.

Guess that’s not gonna happen any time soon.

I imagine in the next collective bargaining agreement, restrictions on viewership will be even tighter. Yippee!

Contact me in 12 years when the NFL has suffered the fate of professional boxing.

Another day, another Hurricane getting screwed. What else is new?

I agree with your general premise – the NFL (and PLEASE GOD, the NBA) needs to hold its officials to a higher standard. On the other hand, I understand the anonymity factor – kind of like U.S. judges – and I’m not for reviewing penalties, if only because it would slow the game down.

I think the trend is probably toward taking power/judgment calls away from the officials (ex. axing the force-out rule), but yeah, it seems if these guys had more to lose (i.e. via public floggings) they’d maybe be a little more on top of things.

Tough job, though. And, along with placekicker, one of the two league gigs I wouldn’t want.

games should be decided on the field by the players. fans are entitled to witness a fair play. there is no consistancy to their calls. example….harrison gets penalized and fined for helmet to helmet contact but in the same game ray lewin almost takes heinz ward’s head off and no penalty called. anything the officials do (or fail to do)should be reviewable. each team gets a set ammount of reviews so what does it matter what they decide to use them on? even reviews should be rewiewable!!! no officials should have the power to control the outcome of a game

 
*name

*e-mail

web site

leave a comment


 
  • Recent Comments